Quick ID
estateRUTH.
Comparable Sales Report
Illinois Watch Co. 'Sterling' 17-Jewel Pocket Watch, c. 1923
Illinois Watch Company, Springfield, Illinois, USA · Early 1920s Art Deco
2
Verified Comps
$200 – $300
FMV Range
85%
Confidence[M]
Identification
The subject item is best identified as Illinois Watch Co. 'Sterling' 17-Jewel Pocket Watch, c. 1923, Early 1920s Art Deco, Illinois Watch Company, Springfield, Illinois, USA. Springfield's Illinois Watch Company was a titan of American horology, widely respected for producing heavily decorated movements that rivaled Swiss imports. The 'Sterling' model was marketed during the Roaring Twenties as a gentleman's essential technology, promising industrial accuracy in an elegant form. The 14kt gold-tone-filled S.W.C.CO. case paired a durable base-metal core with luxurious gold-tone plating, decorated with intricate Art Deco engine turning. Produced circa 1923, this watch bridges the transition from the bulky railroad standard chronometers to the sleek, status-driven accessories of the Jazz Age.
Valuation
$200 – $300
Insurance / Replacement: $450
Auction FMV · 85% confidence High
This is a circa 1923 Illinois Watch Company 'Sterling' grade pocket watch, featuring a 17-jewel movement housed in an ornate 14kt gold-tone-filled case by the Star Watch Case Company (S.W.C.CO.). Valuation is anchored by the exact reference configuration, the high-grade mechanical finishing, and the preservation of its Art Deco aesthetics. Assuming an unserviced, watch-only condition, the estimate reflects secondary market auction hammer prices, sharply separated from the premiums commanded by fully restored retail examples.
Market Analysis
The market for early 1920s American pocket watches is highly stratified based on mechanical condition and original configuration. Direct sold comparables establish a strict floor of approximately $225 for non-running 'parts' watches or examples with severe case wear. Fully serviced, chronometer-timed examples retailed by horology specialists establish a definitive ceiling of $400 to $575. Without evidence of recent mechanical overhaul, this watch must be evaluated in the 'running but unserviced' lane. A comparable 21-jewel Illinois 'Sterling' sold for $300 on the secondary open market; considering the subject is a slightly lower-tier 17-jewel variant, an auction hammer expectation naturally falls into the $200 to $275 bracket, reserving the upper bounds for examples with pristine enamel dials and zero case 'brassing'.
Value Drivers
▲ Confirmed 'Sterling' grade 17-jewel mechanical movement, highly regarded for reliability.
▲ Original S.W.C.CO. case matching the era and production specifications of the Illinois Watch Company.
▲ Ornate engine-turned Art Deco case engravings and stylized dial typography.
▲ Absence of precious metal scrap value isolates the piece's worth entirely to its horological and aesthetic preservation.
Concerns
▼ Lack of verified service history significantly reduces peer-to-peer liquidity and necessitates an 'untested' valuation.
▼ Any 'brassing' (wear exposing the base metal core on the gold-tone-filled case) will severely negatively impact value.
▼ Hairline cracks in the dial enamel or oxidation on the hands immediately place the item toward the $200 floor.
▼ Lacks original presentation box or factory paperwork, typical for the era but standardizing it in the 'watch-only' lane.
🏛 Best Venue
Specialized vintage horology forums (e.g., WatchUSeek) or online auction marketplaces (eBay) with comprehensive macro photography of the movement and case markings.
📈 Upside Potential
Professional servicing with timing documentation, or the revelation of a flawless dial under macro inspection, could elevate the piece into the $400+ specialty retail tier.
⚠️
Authenticity Notice
Medium risk. While modern counterfeits of this model are rare, 'franken-watches' (marriages of mismatched movements, dials, and cases) are extremely common in vintage pocket watches. Verification of the S.W.C.CO. case serial (6813310) against 1920s production dates confirms original manufacturer configuration.
Comparable Sales (2)
Etsy ↗ 2023/2024
$577.50
Antique 1923 Illinois Watch Co. "Sterling" 17-Jewel Pocket Watch (Gold-Filled Case)
HIGH SOLD
BidSpirit / Olde Trove Auction House ↗ April 2021
$260.00
Illinois Watch Co. pocket watch in a 14K gold-filled case
MEDIUM SOLD
‹
›
✕
Research Details
1
Rounds
2
Verified Comps
0/0
Questions
—
Context Sources

Have something you're curious about?

Get your own free report →
Want a report like this for your own item?
Snap a photo. Get the story, the comps, and the value — free.
Try it free →
This report uses internet-based research techniques and should be used as a reference guide only. Critical input variables such as condition, provenance, rarity, and regional demand may not be fully captured and can alter value considerably. Auction results may include buyer's premium. Always verify data with primary sources before making purchasing or selling decisions. This does not constitute a formal appraisal.
Generated by estateRUTH.