Comparable Sales Report
Illinois Watch Company 'Sterling' Grade Pocket Watch, c. 1915-1925
Illinois Watch Company, Springfield, Illinois, USA · Early 20th Century (Art Nouveau/Art Deco Transition)
Identification
The subject item is best identified as Illinois Watch Company 'Sterling' Grade Pocket Watch, c. 1915-1925, Early 20th Century (Art Nouveau/Art Deco Transition), Illinois Watch Company, Springfield, Illinois, USA. Independent production ceased after Hamilton acquired the company in 1928, making original Springfield-marked movements highly collectible today. The Illinois Watch Company was a titan of the early 20th-century American timekeeping revolution, operating from a massive Springfield factory complex. The 'Adjusted 3 Positions' regulation signifies superior factory tuning, elevating this model's reliability above standard mass-market consumer watches. Produced around 1922, this watch represents the final flourishing of the elegant pocket watch era before wristwatches dominated following World War I.
Valuation
$200 – $350
Insurance / Replacement: $525
Auction FMV · 80% confidence
High
This is an authentic Illinois Watch Company 'Sterling' grade pocket watch, securely dated to approximately 1922 based on the movement serial number (4085558). The piece features an 'Illinois Sterling' marked dial and a movement adjusted to three positions, representing a high-quality consumer dress watch of the Art Deco era. As the case material is currently unverified by independent hallmark testing, the valuation strictly defaults to an 'untested metal' or gold-tone lane in a watch-only configuration. The estimated range reflects raw secondary market outcomes for intact, unserviced examples without original accessories.
Market Analysis
Direct comparable sales for early 1920s Illinois 'Sterling' and similarly adjusted pocket watches outline a clear market stratified by case material and mechanical service history. Raw, unserviced examples with unverified or gold-tone-filled cases consistently realize $250 to $260 at auction and on secondary platforms like eBay. Fully serviced examples sold through specialized horological dealers command retail premiums between $350 and $490. A gold-tone metal (untested)-tone metal (untested) comparable achieved $875; however, because our subject lacks precious metal verification, this gold-tone metal (untested) result establishes a strict ceiling rather than a midpoint. Consequently, the Fair Market Value is anchored to the 'untested metal', unserviced lane, recognizing the strong originality of the matching dial and movement.
Value Drivers
▲ Original 'Illinois Sterling' dial perfectly aligning with the movement signature
▲ Movement is 'Adjusted to 3 Positions', elevating it above base-tier mass-market models
▲ Serial number (4085558) securely dates production to c. 1922, a highly desirable Art Deco era
Concerns
▼ Unverified case material forces the piece into a lower 'untested metal/gold-tone' valuation bracket
▼ Unknown mechanical condition (timing stability, lubrication state) assumes an unserviced baseline
▼ Watch-only configuration lacks the original presentation box and factory timing papers
🏛 Best Venue
Specialized horological platforms (e.g., Chrono24, NAWCC forums) or eBay for raw examples.
📈 Upside Potential
Confirmation of a 14K or gold-tone metal (untested)-tone metal (untested) case via professional hallmark testing, or proof of a recent mechanical overhaul, would double the valuation.
⚠️
Authenticity Notice
Risk Level: Low-Medium. While outright counterfeits of consumer Illinois watches are rare, 'franken-watches' (movements swapped into incorrect or aftermarket cases) are common. Buyers verify originality by checking that case screw marks align and that dial branding perfectly matches movement signatures.
Comparable Sales (3)
Antique 1923 Illinois Watch Co 'Sterling' Grade 17-Jewel Pocket Watch (Serial 4241742)
HIGH
SOLD
Vintage 1920s 'Sterling' Model Illinois Pocket Watch (19 Jewel, 16 Size)
MEDIUM
SOLD
"The Garland" 17-Jewel Pocket Watch (12s) Movement: Model 3, Double Roller. Case: 10K Gold-Filled.
MEDIUM
SOLD
‹
›
✕
Want a report like this for your own item?
Snap a photo. Get the story, the comps, and the value — free.
Try it free →