Comparable Sales Report
Roseville Pottery Futura Octagonal Compote, c.1928
Roseville Pottery Company, Zanesville, Ohio · Late 1920s Art Deco
The Maker
The Roseville Pottery Company of Zanesville, Ohio, was a powerhouse of American commercial art pottery in the early-to-mid 20th century. Originally founded in 1890, the company shifted to art pottery under the direction of Frederick Rhead and later Frank Ferrell. The 1920s saw Roseville experimenting heavily with various finishes, transitioning from realistic floral motifs to bold, modernist designs.
Roseville's production spanned several distinct stylistic eras. The high-gloss, metallic finishes of their Lustre line (introduced circa 1921) captured the late-Edwardian fascination with iridescent parlor wares. By 1928, designer Frank Ferrell introduced the 'Futura' line, which abandoned iridescence entirely in favor of avant-garde, geometric shapes finished in matte or textured 'volcanic' glazes. Today, Roseville remains highly collected, though market premiums heavily favor specific eras and lines, with matte-glazed Art Deco forms like Futura commanding the highest institutional and collector interest.
Valuation
$50 – $90
Insurance / Replacement: $150
Auction FMV · 75% confidence
High
While identified by the title as a 1928 Roseville Futura piece, the visual description of a 'pink iridescent footed dish' diagnostically points away from the matte Futura line and directly aligns with Roseville's earlier Lustre line (c. 1921) or Tuscany line (c. 1928). True Futura pieces feature matte or semi-gloss finishes and command significant Art Deco premiums. Therefore, this valuation anchors on comparable sales for pink lusterware and pink-glazed octagonal compotes by Roseville rather than the higher-premium Futura market. Assuming excellent condition without restoration, fair market value is projected between $50 and $90.
Market Analysis
There is a critical identification conflict in the subject item's description: true 1928 Futura pieces were never produced with iridescent glazes, and Futura vases and bowls routinely realize $150 to $500+ at auction. However, the visual description of a 'pink iridescent footed dish' strongly matches Roseville's Lustre line or the octagonal pedestal forms of the Tuscany line. Recent sales for damaged Pink Lustre compotes sit near $30, while an intact Tuscany pink octagonal bowl recently sold for $98 on the secondary market. Retail specialist pricing for intact Lustre forms rests near $147. Anchoring on these glaze and form matches—and excluding the high-tier Futura-specific comps—the fair market auction value for an intact pink iridescent compote is estimated at $50 to $90. Any crazing, hairlines, or rim chips would penalize this value downward to the $20–$30 range.
Value Drivers
▲ Verification of the true glaze and pattern line (Lustre vs. Tuscany)
▲ Integrity of the iridescent glaze, which is highly susceptible to aesthetic degradation
▲ Absence of rim chips, crazing, or base hairlines common to ceramic pedestal forms
▲ Presence of clear factory base marks, such as blue crayon shape numbers or 'Rv' ink stamps
Concerns
▼ Diagnostic mismatch: An iridescent piece cannot be valued at matte Futura market levels.
▼ Condition penalties: High-gloss and iridescent glazes show aesthetic wear much faster than matte glazes.
▼ Material ambiguity: Pink iridescent footed dishes are frequently misidentified pink Carnival glass (e.g., Fenton), which requires physical verification.
▼ Softening market demand for early 1920s lusterware compared to later Art Deco matte lines.
🏛 Best Venue
Online marketplace (eBay or Etsy)
📈 Upside Potential
If physically inspected and proven to be an anomalous, highly experimental factory-iridescent Futura piece (highly improbable but theoretically possible), the value could jump to the $150–$250 tier.
⚠️
Authenticity Notice
Medium risk. While counterfeit Roseville exists, fakes typically target high-value lines (like Pinecone or genuine Futura). Misidentification—specifically confusing depression-era pink Carnival glass for pottery—is the higher risk here. Verify the material is ceramic and check for definitive factory base marks.
Comparable Sales (3)
Vintage 1928 Roseville Pottery Futura Brown #188-8 Aztec Bowl
MEDIUM
SOLD
Roseville Pottery Pink Lustre Compote / Pedestal Bowl Luster Glaze (7.5" H x 9.25" W)
MEDIUM
SOLD
Roseville Lustre Pink Vintage Art Deco Pottery Ceramic Vase 172-9
MEDIUM
SOLD
‹
›
✕
Want a report like this for your own item?
Snap a photo. Get the story, the comps, and the value — free.
Try it free →